Essay ·
Good vibes only is bad advice
What science, philosophy, and even the manifestation gurus say about saying the annoying thing out loud.
The grade came in: 95. Then the news that our project was one of the top 3 in the class.
I called a close friend right away, smiling so hard my cheeks hurt. “I’m so happy I got a 95!” And then, because it was also true: “But I’m a little upset. We had a free rider on our team, and now they get this amazing grade because of all the work I put in.”
My friend thought that was a little ridiculous. I got a 95. We were top 3. Who brings up the bad part after news like that?
I didn’t have a good answer. And the question followed me around for the rest of the night, like a pebble in my shoe.
Did I just complain on a good day? Did I put something dark out into the world, right on top of something bright? Somewhere in the back of my head, a voice that sounded a lot like my TikTok feed whispered: watch your words. Speak only what you want to see.
So I did what a behavioral science grad student does with a pebble. I took it out and turned it over. I read the research. Then the philosophy. Then, honestly, a lot of manifestation books.
It didn’t start where I expected. It started with an arrow.
The second arrow
About 2,500 years ago, the Buddha asked his students a question. When something painful happens, what’s the difference between someone who has trained their mind and someone who hasn’t?
Both feel the pain, he said. Then he painted a picture. A man is hit by an arrow. It hurts. Then, right after, a second arrow lands in the same spot. Now it hurts twice.
The first arrow is the thing that happens. The second arrow is everything we do with it. We replay it. We fight it. We run from it into anything that feels better.
I read that and thought of my phone call. The free rider was the first arrow. The pebble, the worry that I’d done something wrong just by saying it out loud, was the second.
But which part was the mistake? Saying it? Or worrying that I’d said it?
That’s harder to answer than it sounds. There’s a whole world out there that says the mistake was saying it. And some of its arguments are better than you’d think.
The case against complaining
I found five big arguments against what I did on that call. Some come from science. Some come from spirituality. One came straight from my friend.
I’m going to give each one its best shot first, the way the people who believe it would. Then my two cents.
Argument 1: “Your words are a magnet”
The claim
Start with the oldest idea there is: speech makes things.
In the Rig Veda, one of the oldest texts in the world, speech isn’t just a tool. She’s a goddess named Vak, and in one hymn she speaks in her own voice, describing herself as a power that moves through all the worlds. The Bible opens with God speaking light into the dark. The Gospel of John goes further: in the beginning was the Word. Long before TikTok, people believed the first things ever made were made with sound.
The modern version is more practical, and a straight line runs through it. A clockmaker in 1830s Maine named Phineas Quimby watches a traveling hypnosis show and decides that beliefs can make people sick or well. His ideas grow into the New Thought movement. A century later, Rhonda Byrne, grieving her father, is handed a 1910 New Thought book called The Science of Getting Rich, and it becomes the seed of The Secret. Louise Hay sharpens the whole idea into one line: “every complaint is an affirmation.” And today the line ends on a kitchen counter, where someone films two jars of rice, one praised and one cursed, waiting to see which one rots.
You might roll your eyes at the rice. But here’s what makes this argument hard to dismiss. Science has found magnets of its own.
In 2020, doctors in London asked 60 people who had quit cholesterol pills because of side effects to try again for a year. Each month they took the real pill, a sugar pill, or nothing, without knowing which. On the sugar pills, they hurt almost as much as on the real thing. About 90 percent of the symptoms showed up with the fake pills too. They expected pain, and pain came. Doctors call this the nocebo effect.
Then there’s Nick. A researcher named Will Felps hired an actor named Nick and quietly planted him in 40 small teams that were building a business plan. In some teams Nick played a jerk. In some he played a gloomy pessimist. In some he played a slacker. In almost every team, the work came out 30 to 40 percent worse. And the others began to catch his mood, like a cold moving around a room.
And in 2014, Facebook quietly thinned out the happy posts in about 690,000 people’s feeds for a week. Those people then wrote slightly sadder posts themselves. The effect was tiny. But it was there.
So maybe the universe isn’t listening. But people are. Moods travel. Expectations turn into symptoms. And if that’s true, maybe my friend was right to wince. Maybe every complaint really is a small magnet, pulling the room a little darker.
My two cents
I sat with this one for a long time, because I believe most of it. Words do have power.
But look at how the power moves in every one of those stories. The patients spent a year swallowing pills they believed would hurt them. Nick sat in each room for the whole session, sighing, sulking, dragging his feet. The Facebook feeds were a full week of scrolling. The magnet is real. But it’s built out of patterns, not sentences. It’s the voice that never stops, not the one that tells the truth once.
And there’s a detail in the Nick study I can’t stop thinking about. One of his three roles was the slacker. In the actual research, the person who drags the whole team down isn’t the one who names the problem. It’s the free rider.
Then I went back to the teachers, and they turned out to be gentler than their followers. Louise Hay, the same woman who called every complaint an affirmation, also recorded a whole program on releasing anger. In it she says feeling anger is part of the process, and “perfectly okay.” One of her affirmations is: “I am peaceful with all of my emotions.” Peaceful with. Not peaceful without.
Even the maps of “vibration” say it, if you read them closely. On David Hawkins’ famous scale of emotions, acceptance sits far above anger. (His numbers came from muscle testing, which fails when it’s tested blind. Still.) And energy healers link the throat chakra to speaking your truth. What worries them isn’t the spoken word. It’s the swallowed one.
So where did my fear come from, if not from the teachers? Psychologists have a name for it: thought-action fusion. It’s the belief that thinking or saying something makes it more likely to happen. It was first described in 1996 and is studied as a thinking trap tied to anxiety and OCD. In therapy, you don’t obey it. You loosen it, one finger at a time.
Followed all the way down, that fear has a cost. The psychotherapist John Welwood called it spiritual bypassing: using spiritual ideas to step around pain instead of walking through it. In 2023, researchers in Australia found that people who strongly believe in manifestation felt more successful, but were also more drawn to risky investments, and more likely to have gone bankrupt. It’s a link, not proof that one causes the other. But I keep picturing it: someone so busy guarding their vibe that they stop looking at the numbers.
Argument 2: “Complaining shrinks your brain”
The claim
This one wears the best costume. A 1996 Stanford study, the story goes, found that complaining for 30 minutes or more, or even just listening to someone else complain, physically damages your brain. It shrinks the hippocampus, the small, curled, seahorse-shaped part that helps you learn and remember. CNBC ran it. LinkedIn loves it. It shows up in office slide decks next to a glowing picture of a brain.
If it’s true, my phone call didn’t just dim my vibe. It cost me brain cells.
My two cents
I went looking for the study. There isn’t one.
The Ontario Science Centre once used this exact claim to teach people how to spot misinformation. They followed the link back to the Stanford source and searched the page for the word “complain.” Nothing.
What the viral posts seem to be pointing at is Stanford’s coverage of the neuroscientist Robert Sapolsky, who spent decades studying stress, much of it in rats and baboons. That year he wrote a short piece in Science called “Why Stress Is Bad for Your Brain.” It was about severe, long-term stress, the kind that comes with combat trauma and major depression, and stress hormones that stay high for months and years. No complaining. No 30 minutes.
Somewhere between a lab full of stressed rats and a LinkedIn carousel, a finding about trauma turned into a warning against telling your friend about your group project.
And still. Long-term stress does change the brain. That part is real. Which leaves an uncomfortable question hanging: what turns a passing annoyance into long-term stress?
Argument 3: “Your brain will get hooked on negativity”
The claim
This one sounds the most scientific. Neuroscientists like to say that neurons that fire together wire together. Every time you complain, the argument goes, you lay down a little more track. The author Travis Bradberry described it in a piece that went viral: repeat a behavior like complaining, and your neurons reach toward each other to make it easier next time. One complaint today. A groove tomorrow. A highway by next year.
And honestly, this one is partly right. Habits are real. Anyone who has replayed the same grievance in the shower for a week knows how deep a groove can get.
My two cents
The trouble is the cure it prescribes: don’t say it, don’t think it, shove it out of your mind.
In 1863, Dostoevsky slipped a little dare into a travel essay. Try not to think of a polar bear, he wrote, and you’ll see it comes to mind every minute.
More than a hundred years later, a Harvard psychologist named Daniel Wegner took the dare seriously. He sat people in a room with a bell, asked them to say whatever came into their heads for five minutes, and gave them one rule: don’t think about a white bear. If it slips in, ring the bell.
The bell kept ringing. More than once a minute, on average. And later, when people were finally allowed to think about the bear, the ones who had fought it couldn’t stop.
Feelings behave a lot like that bear. Across lab studies, daily diaries, and six months of follow-up, the psychologist Brett Ford and her colleagues found that people who accept their negative feelings end up having fewer of them. The ones who fight their feelings keep them company longer.
So the groove is real. But I’m no longer sure the one honest sentence is what carves it. I think it might be the bell. The checking. The ringing, and ringing, and ringing.
Argument 4: “Just be grateful. You got a 95!”
The claim
This is my friend’s argument, and it’s the most human one. No neurons, no frequencies. Just: you got good news, so hold it. Why drag a cloud across a sunny day? There’s something a little ungrateful about polishing the one scratch on a trophy.
My two cents
I am grateful. But “be grateful” and “don’t mention the other thing” are not the same instruction. The space between them is where it gets uncomfortable.
In 2000, the writer Barbara Ehrenreich was diagnosed with breast cancer. She was scared and furious, and she said so. Everywhere she turned there were pink ribbons, pink teddy bears, bright cheerful advice. When she shared her anger with other patients, she was told, more or less, to fix her attitude. Later she wrote that the pressure to stay positive could weigh on a cancer patient “like a second disease.”
A second disease. A second arrow.
William James knew that weight from the inside. In 1902, in a book about religious experience, he described a “French correspondent” who was struck by sudden terror one evening at dusk. The man remembered a young patient he had once seen in an asylum, who sat all day on a bench with his knees drawn up to his chin, staring at nothing. And the thought arrived: that shape am I. Years later, James admitted the French correspondent was himself.
So when James looked at the mind-cure movement, the great-grandparent of manifestation, he understood its pull better than most. He even stood up for mind-cure healers when Massachusetts lawmakers tried to restrict them. But he could not accept its central promise. An outlook that refuses to look at the bad, he wrote, is “inadequate as a philosophical doctrine,” because the bad is “a genuine portion of reality.” He had sat on that bench, at least in his mind.
Modern research leans his way. A team that studied more than 37,000 people found that those who felt a wider mix of emotions, the hard ones included, had less depression. They call it emodiversity, and they describe the mind like an ecosystem. A forest with only one kind of tree isn’t healthy. It’s a farm, and one disease can wipe it out.
The Danish psychologist Svend Brinkmann pushed further in a half-joking book called Stand Firm, which defends our right to complain. His point is that the real problem isn’t complaining. It’s being forced to pretend that life isn’t hard.
And then there’s Sara Ahmed, who paints the scene I keep coming back to. A family is gathered around a dinner table. Plates are passing, someone is laughing. Then one woman says that something is wrong. The table goes quiet, and everyone turns to look. Not at the problem. At her. Ahmed calls her the feminist killjoy: the person blamed for the bad feeling, as if it began the moment she named it.
Ahmed lived it. In 2016 she resigned as a professor at Goldsmiths, University of London, in protest at how the university handled complaints of sexual harassment. Years later she wrote a whole book on complaint, and one line from it stays with me: “To be heard as complaining is not to be heard.”
My phone call was not a harassment case, and my friend is not the villain here. But I recognized the shape. I named something unfair, and the conversation became about whether I should have named it. The free rider slipped quietly out of the story. And I was the one at the table.
Argument 5: “Good people don’t say negative things”
The claim
This one I can’t wave away, because it doesn’t come from TikTok. It comes from some of the oldest books we have.
The Bhagavad Gita describes the discipline of speech as words that are truthful, pleasant, helpful, and that don’t stir up distress in others. An old Sanskrit verse often quoted beside it is even stricter: speak the truth, speak what is pleasant, don’t speak an unpleasant truth, and never speak a pleasant lie.
Held up to that, my sentence fails before it’s finished. True, maybe. Pleasant, no. I could have said “I got a 95!” and let the rest go quiet.
My two cents
Read that verse again, slowly, and you’ll feel a knot in the middle of it. When truth and kindness pull in different directions, it asks you to hold your tongue. But there is one door it never opens, under any condition: the pleasant lie.
The Buddha loosened the knot a little. In a teaching called the Abhaya Sutta, he says he never speaks what is false or useless. But when something is true and helpful, even if it’s unwelcome, he knows the right moment to say it.
So a negative truth can pass, if it’s helpful and said with care. A pleasant falsehood never does.
Here’s how I hold my sentence up to that light. If I’d said “that guy is lazy,” or wished something bad on him, I’d fail every test in the book. That isn’t truth. It’s a verdict, and it’s built to sting.
But I didn’t say that. I said I did the work that was meant for three people. That’s true. And I think it was helpful, at least to me. There has to be room to stand back from the thing you built and say: damn, I did that alone, and I killed it alone.
Smiling and saying “we did great” would have been the pleasant lie.
Where the critics have a point
After all that, you might think I’m telling everyone to complain more. I’m not. The critics are right about one thing, and it’s easiest to see with a punching bag.
In 2002, the psychologist Brad Bushman made about 600 college students angry on purpose. Each wrote a short essay and got it back with a nasty comment scrawled on it by another student. (There was no other student. The insult was part of the study.)
Then some of them pulled on boxing gloves and hit a punching bag while picturing the person who insulted them. Thud. Thud. Letting it all out, just like pop psychology says you should. Another group hit the bag while thinking about getting fit. A third group sat quietly for two minutes and did nothing at all.
Afterward, everyone got the chance to blast their “partner” with loud noise through headphones. The ones who had punched while picturing the person were the angriest and the cruelest. Sitting quietly beat letting it out. Bushman later compared venting to using gasoline to put out a fire.
The softer version of this happens in friendships every night. It’s 1 a.m. The group chat is still glowing, still circling the same thing it circled yesterday. Psychologists call this co-rumination. Amanda Rose, who named it, found that it does two things at once: it pulls friends closer, and it comes with more anxiety and depression. In one study of female friends, talking problems over this way was linked to a rise in cortisol, the stress hormone.
So pushing it down backfires. And fanning it backfires. Which leaves a smaller, stranger question. What exactly are you supposed to do with the match?
Say it once
The best answer I found is almost 2,000 years old, and it was written by a man who couldn’t follow it.
Seneca’s friend Lucilius had just lost a friend of his own. So Seneca, the great Stoic, sat down to write him a letter. You’d expect a Stoic to say “don’t cry.” Instead he wrote: “Let not the eyes be dry when we have lost a friend, nor let them overflow. We may weep, but we must not wail.”
Then, a few lines later, he confessed. When his own dear friend Annaeus Serenus died, he had cried so hard that he counted himself among those overcome by grief. The man handing out the advice had broken it himself. I trust him more for it.
From ancient China, another scene. When the philosopher Zhuangzi’s wife died, his friend came to comfort him and found him sitting on the floor with his legs sprawled out, drumming on an old pot and singing. The friend was horrified. Zhuangzi looked up and said: when she first died, do you think I didn’t grieve? He had. Then, slowly, he came to see her death as part of the turning of things, like spring giving way to summer. So he stopped crying. And picked up the pot.
People remember the singing. I keep thinking about the grieving that came first.
And then there’s Spinoza. At 23 he was cast out of Amsterdam’s Jewish community for his ideas, and he spent much of the rest of his life grinding glass lenses for a living. Picture that: a man bent over a wheel all day, shaping glass so other people could see clearly. In his great book, published only after he died, he wrote that a feeling “ceases to be a passion, as soon as we form a clear and distinct idea thereof.” See it clearly, and it stops steering you.
About three hundred years later, brain scanners caught up with the lens grinder. When people put a feeling into words, even just naming the emotion in an upsetting photo, the amygdala, the brain’s alarm bell, goes quieter. Therapists shrink it to four words: name it to tame it.
I have to confess a myth of my own here. While researching this, I picked up the idea that venting to a friend releases oxytocin, the “bonding hormone,” and lowers cortisol. It sounded so right. But when I looked closer, no study has actually measured that after a quick comment like mine, and oxytocin turns out to be very hard to measure in people at all. So I won’t sell you an oxytocin hit.
What I can give you is smaller and sturdier. Naming helps. Dwelling hurts. And the line between them isn’t positive versus negative. It’s once, versus over and over.
When manifestation actually works
I don’t want to throw the whole thing out. Plenty of people say manifesting changed their lives, and I believe them. I just think behavioral science tells a better story about why.
My favorite comes from the psychologist Gabriele Oettingen. She asked university students who were about to graduate how often they daydreamed about landing their dream job, and how vivid those daydreams were. Then she waited two years. The students with the most glowing fantasies had gotten fewer job offers, and were earning less.
The dream had done something sneaky. When you picture the win in high definition, part of you feels like you’ve already arrived. So you sit back. In later studies, people who drifted into positive fantasies even showed lower energy, right there in their blood pressure.
But Oettingen also found what works, and there’s a negative thing sitting right at its center. Picture the outcome you want. Then picture, honestly, the thing most likely to get in your way. Then make a plan for it. She calls it WOOP: Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan.
A good complaint, said once, is basically that second O. The obstacle, named out loud.
Here’s how the rest of manifesting lines up with the research:
| What manifesting tells you to do | What’s actually going on | How strong is the evidence? |
|---|---|---|
| Write down exactly what you want | Goal setting (Locke and Latham): specific, hard goals beat “do your best” | Strong, decades of studies |
| Decide when and where you’ll act | If-then plans (Gollwitzer): “If it’s 9am, I open my draft” | Strong: 94 studies, over 8,000 people |
| Picture the win | Mental contrasting, or WOOP (Oettingen), but only when you also name the obstacle | Strong. Fantasy alone lowers energy and effort |
| Believe it will happen | Self-efficacy and optimism: believing you can makes you try harder and keep going | Well supported, when tied to action |
| Expect good things | Self-fulfilling prophecy: your expectations change how you act and how others treat you | Well supported, effects usually modest |
| Keep a gratitude list | Noticing what’s going well | Real but small |
| Journal how you feel | Naming a feeling calms the brain’s alarm (Lieberman and colleagues, 2007) | Supported |
| “I see signs everywhere!” | Selective attention, confirmation bias, and survivorship bias: you notice hits, forget misses, and only hear from people it worked for | Explains a lot of the “proof” |
| Raise your vibration with good feelings | Broaden-and-build (Fredrickson): positive emotions widen attention and build resources | The theory has support. The famous “3-to-1 positivity ratio” was debunked in 2013 and its math withdrawn |
Read down the middle column. Every piece that works is about action, attention, or honesty. Not one of them needs a frequency.
Back to my free rider
More than a hundred years ago, a French farm engineer named Max Ringelmann hooked a rope to a gauge and asked men to pull, first alone, then in groups. As each new pair of hands grabbed the rope, something odd happened. The group pulled harder overall, but each person pulled a little less. Nobody decided to slack. Effort just has a way of disappearing into a crowd.
Long before that, in the 1700s, David Hume pictured two neighbors who agree to drain a soggy meadow they share. Two people can manage it, because each can see if the other is leaning on his shovel. But in a bigger group, Hume wrote, “each seeks a pretext to free himself of the trouble,” and the water just sits there.
My group project was a rope and a meadow.
So was I wrong to feel the sting? Aristotle didn’t think anger was always a failure. “The man who is angry at the right things and with the right people, and, further, as he ought, when he ought, and as long as he ought, is praised.” He thought the opposite was the real flaw: “those who are not angry at the things they should be angry at are thought to be fools.” The words I keep circling are “as long as he ought.” Not forever.
The philosopher Martha Nussbaum gave me the shape I was looking for. Most anger, she argues, carries a quiet wish for payback, and that’s where it goes wrong. But there’s a healthier kind she calls Transition-Anger, and its whole message fits in one breath: “How outrageous. Something should be done about that.” It sees the wrong, then turns to face forward. One of her great examples is Nelson Mandela, who walked out of 27 years in prison talking about the future instead of revenge.
A group project is obviously not apartheid. But the shape fits in the palm of my hand. Name it. Then ask what can be done. Be honest in the peer evaluation. Ask for clear roles next time.
Not everyone thinks anger should be that brief. The philosopher Amia Srinivasan argues that anger at real injustice can stay fitting even when it lasts, even when it hurts the one holding it. She may be right about the big wrongs. This one, I wanted to put down.
How to complain better
- Say it once. Out loud, to a friend, on paper. Then set it down.
- Hold it up to the old test. Is it true? Is it helpful? Am I saying it with care?
- Talk about the work and the feeling, not the person. “I did the work of three” lands very differently from “they’re lazy.”
- Ask Nussbaum’s question. Is there something to be done? If yes, do it. If not, let it go.
- Listen for the bell. Guilt about having a feeling is the second arrow. Fighting the feeling is the bell that keeps ringing.
Both things are true
The Bhagavad Gita doesn’t open with a calm, glowing, high-vibe hero. It opens with a breakdown.
The warrior Arjuna rides out between two armies, looks across the field, and sees his own teachers, cousins, and friends lined up on the other side. His limbs give way. His mouth goes dry. His bow slips from his hand, and he sinks down in his chariot and says he will not fight.
The first chapter is even named for this moment: Arjuna Vishada Yoga, the yoga of Arjuna’s despair. His grief isn’t skipped. It’s the doorway. Everything wise in the Gita comes after a man admits, out loud, how he really feels.
And somewhere in that long conversation is a line that fits my small story better than I expected: your right is to the work, never to its fruits.
I did the work. The 95 is the fruit. Someone else eating from the same tree doesn’t change who planted it.
I’m proud of that grade. I was also a little annoyed. Both are true, and saying both didn’t dim a thing.
I still think about that call, and about my friend’s question. Who brings up the bad part after news like that?
Maybe someone who wants the whole truth to have a seat at the table.
Sources and further reading
Stories and old texts
- Rig Veda 10.125, the hymn of Vak; Genesis 1:3; John 1:1
- The Buddha, Sallatha Sutta (SN 36.6), “The Arrow”
- The Buddha, Abhaya Sutta (MN 58), on true but unwelcome speech
- Bhagavad Gita 17.15, the discipline of speech; Chapter 1 and verse 2.47
- Manusmriti 4.138, “speak the truth, speak what is pleasant”
- William James, The Varieties of Religious Experience (1902)
- Duclow (2002), William James, mind-cure, and the religion of healthy-mindedness
- Seneca, Letter 63, “On Grief for Lost Friends”
- Zhuangzi, Chapter 18, “Supreme Joy”
- Spinoza, Ethics, Part V, Proposition 3
- Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics, Book IV.5 (Ross translation)
- David Hume, A Treatise of Human Nature, 3.2.7, via the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Martha Nussbaum, Anger and Forgiveness (2016)
- Amia Srinivasan, “The Aptness of Anger” (2018)
- Sara Ahmed, Complaint! (2021) and The Promise of Happiness (2010)
- Barbara Ehrenreich, Bright-Sided (2009)
- Svend Brinkmann, Stand Firm (2017)
Manifestation and its history
- The law of attraction and New Thought, including Quimby and Wattles
- Rhonda Byrne, The Secret (2006)
- Louise Hay, 21 Days to Master Affirmations and her anger-release audio
- David Hawkins, Power vs. Force (1995)
- Spiritual bypassing (John Welwood)
- Dixon, Hornsey and Hartley (2023), belief in manifestation
When words really do spread
- The SAMSON trial (2020), statins, sugar pills and the nocebo effect
- Will Felps’ “bad apple” study, as told on This American Life
- Kramer, Guillory and Hancock (2014), emotional contagion on Facebook, PNAS
The brain myths
- Ontario Science Centre, “Does complaining shrink your brain?”
- CNBC (2019), the viral “30 minutes of complaining” article
- Sapolsky (1996), “Why Stress Is Bad for Your Brain,” Science
- Travis Bradberry, “How Complaining Rewires Your Brain for Negativity”
- Wegner and colleagues (1987), the white bear study
- Shafran, Thordarson and Rachman (1996), thought-action fusion
Psychology research
- Quoidbach and colleagues (2014), emodiversity and the emotional ecosystem
- Bushman (2002), venting anger and the punching bag study
- Rose (2002), co-rumination
- Byrd-Craven and colleagues (2008), co-rumination and cortisol
- Lieberman and colleagues (2007), naming emotions and the amygdala
- Ford, Lam, John and Mauss (2018), accepting negative emotions
- Locke and Latham, goal setting; Gollwitzer and Sheeran (2006), if-then plans
- Oettingen and Mayer (2002); Kappes and Oettingen (2011), positive fantasies; Oettingen’s WOOP
- Fredrickson, broaden-and-build; Brown, Sokal and Friedman (2013) on the positivity ratio
- Ringelmann’s rope-pulling studies (published 1913) and social loafing